I see The Real
Music Observer, David Spuria, making some interesting commentaries about
various bands that I have enjoyed for years. So, I'll credit him with
inspiring me to do this. One of my four classic rock go to bands is
Styx. I refer to the classic lineup that included Dennis DeYoung, Tommy
Shaw and James Young along with twin brothers John and Chuck Panozzo.
Rather than talk about the why things are the way they are right now,
I'm going to talk about the possibility of fixing things and giving fans
of the classic Styx lineup the tour they'd like to see. I see two ways
to get DeYoung back in the band. Right now, it seems impossible. Styx
just did a rather impressive album called The Mission this year, and
DeYoung is about ready to record his own solo album after what has been a
successful tour with his own band.
Of course, when they kicked
Dennis out of the band, they needed somebody who would enable them to
continue to do what they do. They needed somebody who could play
keyboards and sing the only Styx songs that Shaw and Young seem to be
able to tolerate from Dennis's catalog. They found their man in Canadian
Popstar, Lawrence Gowan.
The quickest way to facilitate the
possibility of a DeYoung return is for Gowan to leave. Being in Styx was
the opportunity of a lifetime for him. Let's face it, nobody in America
really had a clue who this guy was. He was somewhat popular in Canada.
He doesn't have a bad voice, although it's not really right for the
songs that Dennis sang that he continues to perform in Styx. He is
definitely a showman, and he's a good keyboardist. The problem is, why
would he leave the job of a lifetime? Tommy and James have to be happy
with him because he fills the role they need. He has to be happy because
he's still doing what he loves 20 years later.
The only way for
Lawrence Gowan to step aside would be either because he knows the fans
want to see Dennis with the band one more time, or he willingly takes a
leave of absence from the band. It would be likely that Dennis wouldn't
be a long-term member of the band, but a year's worth of dates would be
enough. Lawrence could return at the end of that time period.
Some people have said Tommy Shaw is the one holding up a DeYoung return.
I don't really believe that to be the case. Tommy has proven that he
didn't need the band to keep his career going. True, he was interested
in reuniting with the band in the late 1980s, but Dennis was about ready
to release his third solo album and had commitments to honor. Tommy
ended up taking the gig with the Damn Yankees and recording one of his
biggest hits, High Enough. In short, Tommy was doing just fine.
Why would this make any difference? Because, if there's a bitterness
that is held against Dennis, it's that he held the band up when others
wanted to make money. If Tommy was out there making money as a solo
artist in the 1980's and early 1990's, the same cannot be said for
either Panozzo brother or Young. I'm not aware of any recording attempts
ever being made by John or Chuck Panozzo. Young recorded albums, but
nothing popped.
Basically, Dennis and Tommy were able to do their
own thing and make money. Both had hits without the band. Then, Dennis
came back when the time was right. Unfortunately, Tommy had other
commitments, and the band went on without him. They had one of their
biggest hits, Show Me The Way, and then things stalled out while they
were working on a follow-up album. Dennis has been blamed for this. If I
recall correctly, Glen Burtnik very directly blamed Dennis for costing
him money, although the two have made peace since then.
James
Young is one heck of a guitar player. Some have called him the balls of
the band. If things got a little too soft, James was the one who kicked
things into high gear. At one time in The Wooden Nickel era, James was
pretty much a lead singer in this band. The Man Of Miracles album can be
regarded as the height of that for James. After that, he still had one
rocker on every album that followed.
Some of his finest moments
include the often played Miss America, Half Penny Two Penny and
Snowblind, both off of Paradise Theater, and the Great White Hope. An
album of all of James's best rockers with the band would be an
interesting record. However, he's more known for co-writing some of
their best hits and his guitar work than for anything he ever sang with
the band.
It was James who notably said that Dennis would be
brought back to the band when they were playing ice hockey on the River
Styx. That pretty much said that James was the one keeping the door
locked and pushing his weight against it. Only James and Chuck remain
with the band from the lineup that got the first record deal, and Chuck
only plays a song or two on the occasional gig. Chuck's main concern was
always that the band be playing so that he could play when he felt up
to it.
It's hard for me to believe that if James suddenly came to
the guys and said that he wanted to bring Dennis back into the band
that this wouldn't happen. Some might say Tommy would be a little bit
miffed, but Tommy's position in this band is solid. And he's had 18
years to lead Styx in the direction they are in. He and James have
pretty much attempted to redefine what this band's legacy is.
Why would James even want to bring back Dennis? This is a good question.
I don't see this current lineup wanting to hang up their guitars
anytime soon. They're enjoying being out on the road. However, to the
notion that Dennis DeYoung didn't want to tour or Rock, I think what
he's done since being kicked out of the band has put an end to that
silly discussion. Why would James want to shake things up and bring
Dennis back? It brings everything full circle.
At this point, it
wouldn't be about the next big Styx hit. Dennis has a track record of
putting this band back up on the charts, but times have changed in the
music industry. Another big hit for the band at this point in their
career seems unlikely. But the Styx hits through the years have
generally spoken of optimism and hope for the future. Maybe the reason
the fanbase is so divided is because the music of this band has spoken
to the hearts of all of them.
It's unfortunate and a bit unfair
that the fans have been forced to pick sides. While you have those fans
who will go to a Styx show or one of the Dennis DeYoung shows and have a
good time, there are many fans who will only go to one or the other
because of their feelings about what happened to break things up. Dennis
has reached out and is ready and willing, so the next move is up to
Styx themselves. If that move is going to be made, it would be up to
James to make it. And why would he do that? Because it's the right thing
to do.
Getting back to Lawrence Gowan, you don't even have to
kick him out of the band to make this happen. Dennis himself has a
second keyboardist in his band. This enables him to step out front of
the stage and be the showman that he is. Gowan has put 18 years into
this band, and I don't think Dennis has animosity towards him. Gowan is
just taking a role that somebody else would have taken had he passed on
the opportunity.
Lawrence might want to take a leave of absence
to let this happen, but he could easily handle keyboard duties and sing a
song off of The Mission, one of his other contributions to the band or
even Criminal Mind. All of the classic Dennis songs would be sung by
Dennis, of course. The fans get to see the three core members and even
Chuck on stage one last time, and everybody can walk away happy at the
end of the tour. It seems simple enough from this point of view, but
when you're in the middle of it, things are a little bit different.
The talk heats up every November when people discuss who the next band
will be in the Hall Of Fame. The body of work that Styx had back in
those days, the way tickets and records sold and the way songs from
those days still touch people's hearts today shows that this is a band
that is worthy. At some point, Styx is going to be inducted into the
Hall Of Fame. When that moment comes, it could be that we finally get
what we were looking for. Then again, if it doesn't happen then, it may
never happen.